EurObserv'ER logo

Biogas in France

 
General


France plans to meet the binding target imposed by Directive 2009/28/EC without resorting to the cooperation mechanisms permitting a part of the renewable energy production efforts to be made via another member country (statistical transfer or joint projects) or via a country that is not a member of the European Union (joint projects). However, France has reaffirmed its commitment in favour of the Mediterranean Solar Plan (MSP). This plan may lead it to put in place cooperation mechanisms (joint projects) with non-member Mediterranean rim countries. In this case, the contribution of additional renewable energies would permit France to exceed its target of 23% of energy produced from renewable resources in the gross final energy consumption in 2020. The ten-year estimation being an exercise subject to numerous uncertainties, it is difficult to estimate to what extent France will be able to use the cooperation mechanisms in the context of the MSP. Therefore this national action plan does not fix a target superior to the 23% target imposed by Directive 2009/28/EC and does not take into account the contribution of renewable energies via one or more joint projects with Mediterranean rim countries. 

 

 

Renewable heat and power: biogas

Feed-in Tariff

The main tool for the support of electricity production facilities, the obligation to purchase electricity concerns all methods of renewable production, and in particular the photovoltaic, wind power and biomass sectors. The associated regulatory texts are Article 10 of Law no. 2000-108 of 10 February 2000, decree no. 2001-410 of 10 May 2001, decree no. 2000-1196 of 6 December 2000, together with, for each sector, the price decree describing the purchase prices and attribution conditions issued by the Energy Minister. The bodies responsible for the obligation to purchase are the electricity distributors (EDF or local distribution companies). The contribution to the public electricity service, paid by all electricity consumers, makes it possible to compensate the electricity distributors for the extra costs linked to the obligation to purchase for renewable origin electricity. Regarding technical specifications, certain purchase prices are modified according to performance criteria: this is particularly the case for biomass where an energy efficiency bonus together with a bonus depending on the biomass type used may be granted. As regards, photovoltaic, a highly incentive bonus for integration into constructions and a bonus for simplified integration into constructions have been in place following the price review in January 2010. The criteria for granting these integration bonuses are binding and are described in the order of 12 January 2010 relating to facilities using radiant solar energy.
The obligation to purchase is opened by Grenelle II law to local and regional authorities and to government-owned corporations that depend directly from them.
The obligation to purchase is entered into for a duration of 15 to 20 years according to the technologies and their degree of maturity. For each sector, the level of purchase prices is periodically reviewed in order to remain in line with the maturity of the sector and the reduction in production costs. The mechanism is financed by the contribution to the public electricity service: the excess electricity purchased by the energy suppliers is distributed over the electricity bills of all users prorata with their consumption.
For the sake of brevity, the table below resumes the main characteristics of purchase prices together with their past development. The details of attribution conditions are provided in the price decrees.


Summary table for Feed in tariffs for biogas electricity

 

Sector

Orders regulating the

purchase of electricity

Duration of

contracts

Example of prices for facilities in service at the date of publication of the orders

Biogas

10 July 2006

15 years

between 7.5 and 9 euro cents/kWh according to the power rating, + energy efficiency bonus between 0 and 3 euro cents/kWh

 

3 October 2001 (valid for

landfill biogas only)

15 years

4.5 to 5.72 euro cents/kWh according to the power rating + energy efficiency bonus between 0 and 0.3 euro cents/ kWh

 

Methanisation

10 July 2006

15 years

between 7.5 and 9 euro cents/kWh according to the power rating, + energy efficiency bonus between 0 and 3 euro cents/kWh + methanisation bonus of 2 euro cents/kWh .

 

16 April 2002

15 years

4.6 euro cents/kWh + energy efficiency bonus between 0 and 1.2 euro cents/kWh

Injection to the grid

The National Agency for Sanitary Safety (ANSES) submitted in October 2008 a report on
the evaluation of sanitary hazards linked to the injection of biogas into the natural gas
network. It concluded that there were no specific sanitary hazards linked to the injection into the network of certain types of purified biogas, compared to natural gas, which helped initiate the debate on the injection of biogas into the natural gas network.
The Grenelle II law provides for the principle of injection of biogas into the natural gas
networks, the obligation to purchase biogas injected by natural gas suppliers at a preferential rate being fixed by legal order, together with the establishing of a compensation system for suppliers taking into account the extra costs linked to the obligation to purchase. No assessment of the need to extend the gas network infrastructure to facilitate the integration of gas from renewable energy sources has yet been carried out. The injection of biogas into the networks is an infant sector. Connection studies are currently being carried out on a case by case basis. An assessment of experience gained is thus necessary before examining this
hypothesis. Regarding the technical rules relating to connection to the network, a technical spécification has been established by the operator of the dominant network. This specification is available on line, on the French Gas Association (AFG) website. In terms of connection prices, these were established by the operator of the distribution network and will be proposed to the regulator when the legislative and regulatory system has been agreed (cf. paragraph above).
In both cases, as for the technical provisions, this information will be published on the Internet site of the network operator(s) and, for prices, on the Internet site of the Energy and Climate Directorate as well.
It is therefore now possible to proceed with this injection while respecting the technical
provisions of the distributors or transporters of natural gas and the provisions relating to the origin of the waste. At present, projects for the injection of biogas into the network may be the subject of Heat Fund support. Discussions are under way to put in place a more specific system to develop this emerging sector.


Future programme changes expected

Regarding the methanisation, the Government wishes to encourage the acceleration of projects to achieve the targets set for 2020 with the establishment of support mechanisms strengthened: first, biogas from anaerobic digestion can be injected networks of natural gas after the publication of new regulations this summer, on the other hand, the purchase rate for electricity produced from biogas is upgraded by the end of April, to become comparable to existing rate in Germany, The revaluation in 2020 will increase about 1% of the electricity bill of consumers, corresponding to a support of 300 million € / year.
The maximum tariff for purchasing electricity generated from methane from 15.2 c€/kWh to 20.1 c€ / kWh. On average, rates will increase by 20%. An incentive will be introduced for processing manure, making projects of particular interest to breeders. Biogas injected directly into the networks will also benefit from a maximum redemption rate of 10.3€ / kWh.
Source of renewable energy, methane is also a great method of treating waste, whether household waste, manure or sewage sludge. By 2020, it should help avoid emissions of carbon dioxide up to 5 million tons.


Feed-in tariffs subject to consultation for methanisation

Electricity from methanisation

 

Range capacity

FIT (c€/kWh)

Maximum value of the premium Energy Efficiency (c / kWh)

Maximum values of the premium processing of livestock manure (c / kWh)

150 kW

13,5

4

2,6

300 kW

12,8

4

1,5

500 kW

12,3

4

0,9

1000 kW

11,8

4

0

2000 kW

11,3

4

0

 

Biogas Injection

 

Débit d’injection

Tarif (c€/kWh)

60m3/h

10,3

Entre 60 et 700 m3/h

Interpolation linéaire entre 10,3 et 5

700 m3/h

5

 


 


Sources

Communiqué de presse du 24 février 2011, du Ministère de l'écologie, du développement durable, du transport et du logement
National action plan for the promotion of renewable energies 2009-2020 In accordance with Article 4 of European Union Directive 2009/28/EC

Interactive EurObserv’ER Database

http://www.eurobserv-er.org

Last update: March 2011